Jimmy Reed — “Jimmy Reed at Carnegie Hall” — Vee Jay Records/Craft Recordings

Jimmy Reed — born Mathis James Reed on Sept. 6, 1925, in
Dunleith, Miss. — has always been one of my favorite blues artists.
If the foggy mist of my memory is correct, I was first entranced by Reed’s distinctive vocals and the easy rhythms of his guitar on the radio — from the Bossman, the Daddio of the Raddio, DJ Porky Chedwick, back in 1950s Pittsburgh.
Fast forward to the mid-1960s, when I briefly shared an apartment with fellow aspiring newspaper reporter Don Wilder, who impressed me with two things:
- He had just returned from the Peace Corps somewhere in Asia — Katmandu, I think — and slept with a long-barreled revolver under his pillow.
- He could play Jimmy Reed songs on his guitar and one of his few possessions (besides the revolver) was a Jimmy Reed album. I don’t remember which one.
I borrowed the album, and I’m almost sorry to say, never returned it.
This is all a roundabout way of saying that this fine new remastered vinyl album, “Jimmy Reed at Carnegie Hall,” has been released by Craft Recordings and its Bluesville label, capturing the essence of Reed’s music that was both accessible and classic in its simplicity.
Spoiler Alert: Although Reed performed at Carnegie Hall on May 13, 1961, sharing the “Blues at Carnegie” bill with Muddy Waters, Big Maybelle, Jimmy Witherspoon and Oscar Brown Jr., the resulting album was not a live recording of that performance. According to the original Vee-Jay liner notes, contractual and technical difficulties prevented the label from recording Reed’s appearance. Vee-Jay subsequently recreated the material in studio sessions, and “Jimmy Reed at Carnegie Hall” arrived later in 1961 as a double LP. This pristine version is not a reissue of the complete original two-record set. Bluesville is reproducing the first LP only, containing the 11 tracks associated with Reed’s Carnegie Hall program.

So, this remastered version includes some studio recreations of the Carnegie Hall performance, along with additional recordings. That’s fine. It’s an excellent tribute to this prolific and influential bluesman, whose music stirred and was covered by artists including Hank Williams Jr., Bob Dylan, Neil Young, and the Rolling Stones. Elvis performed an upbeat version of “Baby What You Want Me To Do” as part of the blues-filled opening segment of his 1968 Comeback Special. And Etta James made a spine-chilling version of the same song part of her live shows. Dylan wrote “Goodbye Jimmy Reed” for his 2020 “Rough and Rowdy Ways” album, an obscure but meaningful tribute (videos below).
Reed’s music was deceptively simple. His churning guitar and high-pitched harp work created a swampy vehicle for his easy-riding vocals. Their power was in that effortless simplicity. He wasn’t a guitar wizard or a blues shouter. The music was — and is — just the pure deep groove of down-home blues.
The songs here are some that Reed made popular between 1956 & 1961, opening with “Bright Lights, Big City,” his most successful recordings on the R&B charts. Others are “I’m Mr. Luck,” “Baby What’s Wrong,” “Found Joy,” “Kind of Lonesome,” “Aw Shucks Hush Your Mouth,” “Tell Me You Love Me,” “Blue Carnegie,” “I’m a Love You,” “Hold Me Close,” and “Blue Blue Water.” His wife, Mary “Mama” Reed, sings delightful backup on “Baby What’s Wrong.” “Blue Blue Water” came as a bit of a surprise — Reed sings in a lower-pitched, more soulful voice than usual, at a slightly slower pace. It’s a gorgeous finale.
Reed’s life was plagued by excessive drinking and a long undiagnosed case of epilepsy, and he died of respiratory failure at the age of 50. He had placed 12 singles on the pop chart, as well as 18 in the R&B Top 20.
Jimmyy Reed left a historic legacy of memorable blues that fill numerous albums. “Jimmy Reed at Carnegie Hall,” in its remastered glory, is a fine update to that legacy.
Here are the videos mentioned above, plus “Bright Lights” from the album:
- “Bright Lights Big City” — 2:48
- “I’m Mr. Luck” — 3:34
- “Baby What’s Wrong” — 3:22
- “Found Joy” — 3:39
- “Kind of Lonesome” — 2:51
- “Aw Shucks Hush Your Mouth” — 2:31
- “Tell Me You Love Me” — 2:53
- “Blue Carnegie” — 2:51
- “I’m a Love You” — 2:05
- “Hold Me Close” — 2:37
- “Blue Blue Water” — 2:41
Highlights – “Bright Lights, Big City,” “What’s Wrong Baby,” “Found Joy,” “Kind of Lonesome,” “Tell Me You Love Me,” “Blue Carnegie,” “I’m a Love You,” “Hold Me Close,” & “Blue Blue Water.”








